Skip advert
Advertisement

Porsche 911 vs Porsche Cayman S

We debate whether the Cayman S makes the 911 redundant or not. What do you think?

Porsche Cayman S - 911 killer?

The new issue of evo debates whether Porsche's Cayman S - and its increasing wealth of talents - is now good enough to eclipse the Porsche 911, the brand's headline car since its creation over 40 years ago.

A £44K Cayman S boasts 237bhp-per-ton, hits 60mph in 5.2sec and tops out at 172mph. A 911 Carrera costs nigh on £18K more, yet it improves these figures by just 8bhp, 0.4sec and 8mph respectively.  The Cayman is also a mid-engined car which many argue has more poise and balance as a result, relegating the 911 to also-ran status.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Can this really be the case? Or does the 911 boast legend-status and history that no model can match? Read Ollie Marriage and John Barker thrash it out, and then have your own say via the new evo Community. You can chat in the forum, write a blog on your favourite and vote in our poll, which is at the bottom of the page.

Skip advert
Advertisement

Recommended

Porsche 911 Carrera T review – the ultimate all-round sports car
Porsche 911 Carrera T
Reviews

Porsche 911 Carrera T review – the ultimate all-round sports car

One of a handful of manual sports cars that remain, the Carrera T is also the most 'affordable' way into a manual 911
22 Sep 2026
Gunther Werks GXR-Evo – how to make a Manthey Racing 911 GT3 RS look tame
Guntherwerks GXR Evo
News

Gunther Werks GXR-Evo – how to make a Manthey Racing 911 GT3 RS look tame

Gunther Werks has taken their restomods to the ultimate extreme, with the fastest naturally aspirated car it's ever made
17 Aug 2026
Theon Design Porsche 911 review – twice a GT3 RS's price, but twice the car?
Theon Design Porsche 911
Reviews

Theon Design Porsche 911 review – twice a GT3 RS's price, but twice the car?

Theon Design's latest Porsche 911 restomod calls back classic racers and costs twice as much as the best new 911. We drive it to see if it's worth it
21 May 2026
Porsche 911 review – more complex than ever, but still the best sports car
Porsche 911
In-depth reviews

Porsche 911 review – more complex than ever, but still the best sports car

The 992-generation 911 has taken time to reveal its character, but it’s evolved into a sports car with enormous breadth and ability
10 Apr 2026
Skip advert
Advertisement

Most Popular

TVR Cerbera (1996-2004) review – the British bargain supercar
TVR Cerbera
Reviews

TVR Cerbera (1996-2004) review – the British bargain supercar

The singular, spectacular Cerbera is a genuine supercar that’s often overlooked – and, arguably, underpriced
2 Nov 2026
BMW i3 50 review – why it's the best electric car we've driven
BMW i3
Reviews

BMW i3 50 review – why it's the best electric car we've driven

The BMW i3 name has returned, but now in a much more conventional form than before. It's quick in 50 xDrive form, and retains Munich's sophisticated d…
30 Oct 2026
The best cars we’ve ever driven – evo’s five-star cars
The best cars ever
Best cars

The best cars we’ve ever driven – evo’s five-star cars

Five-star cars are the very best cars we’ve ever tested, and sure-fire hits for all in search of the thrill of driving
29 Oct 2026